Head-to-Head (18 maç)

• 2026-04-22New York City FC4-4FC Cincinnati (İY 2-1)
• 2025-08-23FC Cincinnati0-1New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2025-05-04New York City FC1-0FC Cincinnati (İY 1-0)
• 2024-11-09FC Cincinnati0-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2024-11-02New York City FC3-1FC Cincinnati (İY 2-0)
• 2024-10-28FC Cincinnati1-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2024-10-02New York City FC3-2FC Cincinnati (İY 1-0)
• 2024-03-23FC Cincinnati1-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2023-08-26FC Cincinnati3-0New York City FC (İY 1-0)
• 2023-05-31New York City FC1-3FC Cincinnati (İY 0-1)
• 2022-09-08New York City FC1-1FC Cincinnati (İY 1-1)
• 2022-06-29FC Cincinnati4-4New York City FC (İY 3-3)
• 2021-09-18FC Cincinnati1-2New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2021-04-24New York City FC5-0FC Cincinnati (İY 1-0)
• 2020-09-26New York City FC4-0FC Cincinnati (İY 3-0)
• 2020-09-12New York City FC2-1FC Cincinnati (İY 1-0)
• 2019-08-17FC Cincinnati1-4New York City FC (İY 1-2)
• 2019-06-06New York City FC5-2FC Cincinnati (İY 3-1)