Head-to-Head (29 maç)

• 2026-07-22Columbus Crew1-2New York City FC (İY 0-1)
• 2026-05-10New York City FC3-0Columbus Crew (İY 2-0)
• 2025-09-17New York City FC3-2Columbus Crew (İY 1-1)
• 2025-03-22Columbus Crew0-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2024-08-31Columbus Crew4-2New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2024-06-14New York City FC2-3Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2023-07-08Columbus Crew1-1New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2023-06-17New York City FC1-1Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2022-08-06Columbus Crew3-2New York City FC (İY 2-1)
• 2022-05-14New York City FC2-0Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2021-07-30New York City FC4-1Columbus Crew (İY 2-0)
• 2021-07-17Columbus Crew2-1New York City FC (İY 1-0)
• 2021-05-23New York City FC1-2Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2020-10-19Columbus Crew3-1New York City FC (İY 1-0)
• 2020-08-24New York City FC1-0Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2020-03-01Columbus Crew1-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2019-08-21New York City FC1-0Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2019-06-01Columbus Crew2-2New York City FC (İY 1-0)
• 2018-09-02Columbus Crew2-1New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2018-07-14New York City FC2-0Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2017-11-05New York City FC2-0Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2017-11-01Columbus Crew4-1New York City FC (İY 1-0)
• 2017-10-22New York City FC2-2Columbus Crew (İY 2-1)
• 2017-04-29Columbus Crew2-3New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2016-10-23New York City FC4-1Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2016-08-13Columbus Crew3-3New York City FC (İY 0-1)
• 2016-04-16Columbus Crew3-2New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2015-08-29New York City FC1-2Columbus Crew (İY 1-1)
• 2015-08-19Columbus Crew2-2New York City FC (İY 1-0)