Head-to-Head (39 maç)

• 2026-05-13New York Red Bulls3-2Columbus Crew (İY 2-1)
• 2025-10-18Columbus Crew3-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2025-08-30New York Red Bulls0-0Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2024-11-03New York Red Bulls2-2Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2024-10-29Columbus Crew0-1New York Red Bulls (İY 0-1)
• 2024-10-20New York Red Bulls2-3Columbus Crew (İY 0-2)
• 2024-03-16Columbus Crew3-0New York Red Bulls (İY 1-0)
• 2023-07-01Columbus Crew2-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2023-03-18New York Red Bulls2-1Columbus Crew (İY 0-1)
• 2022-10-01Columbus Crew2-1New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2022-03-20New York Red Bulls1-1Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2021-10-23Columbus Crew1-2New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2021-09-14Columbus Crew2-1New York Red Bulls (İY 0-1)
• 2021-08-19New York Red Bulls1-0Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2020-11-21Columbus Crew3-2New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2020-07-17Columbus Crew2-0New York Red Bulls (İY 1-0)
• 2019-07-27New York Red Bulls2-3Columbus Crew (İY 1-1)
• 2019-03-02Columbus Crew1-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2018-11-12New York Red Bulls3-0Columbus Crew (İY 1-0)
• 2018-11-04Columbus Crew1-0New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2018-07-28New York Red Bulls2-3Columbus Crew (İY 0-3)
• 2018-06-09Columbus Crew1-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-0)
• 2017-09-23Columbus Crew3-2New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2017-04-22New York Red Bulls2-0Columbus Crew (İY 2-0)
• 2016-10-16New York Red Bulls3-2Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2016-06-25Columbus Crew1-1New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2015-11-30New York Red Bulls1-0Columbus Crew (İY 0-0)
• 2015-11-22Columbus Crew2-0New York Red Bulls (İY 1-0)
• 2015-10-03New York Red Bulls2-1Columbus Crew (İY 2-1)
• 2015-07-04Columbus Crew2-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-1)
• 2015-03-28Columbus Crew1-2New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2014-10-19New York Red Bulls1-3Columbus Crew (İY 0-2)
• 2014-07-12New York Red Bulls4-1Columbus Crew (İY 2-1)
• 2014-04-26Columbus Crew1-1New York Red Bulls (İY 1-0)
• 2013-08-10Columbus Crew2-0New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2013-05-26New York Red Bulls2-2Columbus Crew (İY 1-1)
• 2013-05-04Columbus Crew0-1New York Red Bulls (İY 0-0)
• 2012-09-15New York Red Bulls3-1Columbus Crew (İY 1-1)
• 2012-04-07Columbus Crew1-4New York Red Bulls (İY 0-3)