Head-to-Head (25 maç)

• 2026-07-25New York City FC3-1Chicago Fire (İY 3-1)
• 2025-09-14Chicago Fire1-3New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2025-05-25New York City FC3-1Chicago Fire (İY 0-1)
• 2024-08-24New York City FC2-2Chicago Fire (İY 2-0)
• 2024-07-14Chicago Fire0-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2023-10-22New York City FC1-0Chicago Fire (İY 0-0)
• 2023-03-05Chicago Fire1-1New York City FC (İY 0-1)
• 2022-08-21Chicago Fire0-2New York City FC (İY 0-1)
• 2022-05-22New York City FC1-0Chicago Fire (İY 1-0)
• 2021-10-27New York City FC1-0Chicago Fire (İY 0-0)
• 2021-09-30Chicago Fire2-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2021-08-05Chicago Fire0-0New York City FC (İY 0-0)
• 2020-11-08Chicago Fire3-4New York City FC (İY 3-3)
• 2020-08-29New York City FC3-1Chicago Fire (İY 1-1)
• 2019-05-25Chicago Fire1-1New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2019-04-24New York City FC1-0Chicago Fire (İY 1-0)
• 2018-09-26New York City FC2-0Chicago Fire (İY 0-0)
• 2018-07-01Chicago Fire3-2New York City FC (İY 1-2)
• 2017-10-01Chicago Fire1-1New York City FC (İY 1-1)
• 2017-07-22New York City FC2-1Chicago Fire (İY 0-0)
• 2016-09-24New York City FC4-1Chicago Fire (İY 3-1)
• 2016-04-10New York City FC0-0Chicago Fire (İY 0-0)
• 2016-03-06Chicago Fire3-4New York City FC (İY 1-3)
• 2015-05-15New York City FC2-2Chicago Fire (İY 1-2)
• 2015-04-25Chicago Fire1-0New York City FC (İY 1-0)